Montblanc iron gall ink. Proper IG inks, such as the ESSRI, Diamine Registrars/Akke...
Montblanc iron gall ink. Proper IG inks, such as the ESSRI, Diamine Registrars/Akkerman #10 are completely waterproof, which isn't the case with inks containing some degree of IG. Whew! PS: with Lamy inks, same story. This is a dark navy with gray undertones. The only caveat being, that certain iron gall inks need to be flushed more often. Jul 28, 2023 · This section delves into the specifics of six major ink types typically found in cartridges: dye-based inks, pigment-based inks, iron-gall inks, bulletproof inks, shimmer inks, and scented inks. For some documents, a single wavelength image was enough to restore full legibility. The colour just seems to exude gravitas. But I'd just like to know what Iron Gall ink in general to consider. I Apr 4, 2014 · What Ink To Replace Iron Gall Blue Black? - Page 3 - Montblanc - The Fountain Pen Network All Activity Home Brand Focus Montblanc Iron gall ink (also known as common ink, standard ink, oak gall ink or iron gall nut ink) is a purple-black or brown-black ink made from iron salts and tannic acid s from vegetable sources. IG is a permanent ink made from combining iron salts with tannic acid (often extracted from Oak Galls). Sep 7, 2009 · For me lamy blue- black is an other ink which contain some iron gall ink, but in safari nib this inkis better than Montblanc, and from the information of Lamy service without problem. Jun 15, 2019 · As far as I know, the only Akkerman ink that is an iron gall ink is Ijzer Galnoten (is that #10? I don't remember the numbers, just the names), from their regular line. I could easily put my hands on manuscripts that had been written in iron gall inks, in which the ink ate through the paper and left mostly sheets of what looked like laser cut lace. Jun 5, 2024 · So, you should definitely avoid any “calligraphy” or traditional iron gall inks and any India inks. I agree with your concern re: the steel nose cone and iron gall inks. The initial hue, a rich, cool black derived from iron tannates, undergoes a gradual oxidation process, leading to a brownish undertone and eventual fading. The colours of the iron Oct 11, 2018 · I have done extended tests on modern iron gall inks here, here and here — just to prove that modern iron galls from reputable makers are safe for extended time periods in pens with stainless steel nibs. Nov 10, 2015 · We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Oct 6, 2013 · Hi all, I picked up a bottle of the reformulated Midnight Blue yesterday, below are some photos and some first thoughts. Yes, really ascorbic acid and citric acid can clean the iron gall ink from the pen. With these pigments, the ink corresponds to ISO 14145-2 (documentary use). Thank you for visiting JetPens, our online stationery store that carries the best pens, paper, and art supplies from Japan and beyond! Our mission is to spread the joy of creativity through the analog tools we've picked out just for you. Jul 7, 2021 · One of my most frequently used “workhorse” inks has been TWSBI Blue-Black, a modern iron gall blue-black ink in the tradition of classic Pelikan Blue-Black, Lamy Blue-Black, and old-formulation Montblanc Midnight Blue. Priced 25¢ right there on the box. I don't let ink sit in an idle pen, and most often used nothing but plain water to flush the pens. Victoria Esperanza and 69 others Muralikkrishnan S Jan 22 I love and love the ink - Montblanc Great Aug 29, 2023 · If you want to write elegant pointed pen calligraphy with hairline upstrokes, iron gall ink is a must-try! This historical ink is pure joy. Luca My Writing Instruments (selection): Graf von Faber-Castell, Classic, 18k nib in ebony wood dress Mar 23, 2013 · Instead, modern surrogate iron gall formulas such as blue-black bottled inks by Lamy, Montblanc, Chesterfield's Archival Vaultor, Diamine Registrar's Ink, Ecclesiastical Stationery Supplies Registrars Ink, Gutenberg Urkundentinte G10 Schwarz (certificate ink G10 black) or Rohrer & Klingner "Salix" and "Scabiosa" inks are offered for fountain pens. Most of mine are vintage and getting hard to find reliably these days -- Montblanc's offering in Midnight Blue was iron gall up until about a year or two ago, sadly. Montblanc permanent black is a fantastic ink on copy paper and the regular cheaper always available stationary - very impressed. . MB stopped making it due to changes in EU regulations around 2013. The chemical reactions that cause Iron-Gall ink to darken on paper can occur inside the pen. Also the workload you place on your vintage pen would do more harm to your vintage pen than a modern iron gall ink would. Herbin Perle Noire to the permanent Platinum Carbon Black. Criteria - won't bleed or feather using a western <F> or <M> nib. When first applied to paper, the ink appears pale gray; as it is exposed to air, the ink darkens to a rich blue-black tone. Check out our iron gall ink spencerian love selection for the very best in unique or custom, handmade pieces from our calligraphy shops. Expecting it to be royal blue, Sep 5, 2020 · Recently I've been looking to save on paper and have had some issues with bleed through with the paper, and I've heard that iron gall inks are pretty good for those kinds of paper. All write on the dry side of the equation. In particular, older iron gall inks can precipitate out due to the effects of evaporation and air, leading to small particulate in the ink. I love blue black and dark blue ink. I desperately want to like this ink. It is quite stunning. Iron-gall inks have generally good water-resistance. People are overly worried and the ink makers listened. Mar 30, 2021 · A Jinhao 159, x450, x750 and a pen of the day are used to get a range of experience with the ink. Jul 29, 2012 · I worked for years in the Harvard University library system, in special collections (rare books and archives), and iron gall ink was notorious for eating away at the paper substrates. Montblanc Midnight Blue has not been iron gall since ~2012. Nov 22, 2024 · The Montblanc Midnight Blue (the older formula) was Iron Gall too, so iron galls are fine for most FPs. Oct 6, 2012 · I've used iron-gall inks for years with all my pens for years without any special cleaning regimen, and encountered no problems at all. The old bottles with iron gall are still around-it's one of my favorite inks and I have a few bottles-but the current formula is all dye based. I reserve the right to remove any which are vulgar or which are cruel or rude to any individual. Jan 24, 2014 · Does anyone know if the new permanent black and blue inks are iron gall or reactive dye based? I wonder also if there would be any problems if the inks are mixed? Thanks. To avoid it, you need a gold nib. Iron gall ink Oak galls and iron (II) sulfate, ingredients of iron gall ink Iron gall ink (also known as common ink, standard ink, oak gall ink or iron gall nut ink) is a purple-black or brown-black ink made from iron salts and tannic acids from vegetable sources. These inks are also available in cartridges for pens that use them. Apr 3, 2025 · [13] This was confirmed from Montblanc in a personal email to myself, available here. I am trying to make a list here of similar inks that work fantastic on regular copy paper. Diamine offers some, too, along with the Chesterfield Archival (same juice?). I have both of these. Mont Blanc Midnight is the darkest, and the slowest to dry. From what I've read, Montblanc's Midnight Blue is an iron gall ink. Background: The old formula Midnight Blue has been a much loved 'iron gall' ink, an ink which contains a component that seems to result in fantastic performance, very little bl Aug 2, 2014 · I would agree that Pelikan Blue Black isn't a straight iron gall ink, but just as the old Lamy Blue Black and old Montblanc Midnight Blue, I believe it contains some element of iron gall, which is why it was included in the test. It's also an iron gall ink which is permanent on paper. Also, if anyone knows where one can find the old Montblanc Midnight Blue or suggest what a reasonable price on eBay would be, that'd be awesome, too! Thanks! May 25, 2010 · Mont Blanc pens are very tough and their own black ink is an iron gall ink, which should only be used in a pen with a gold nib. Jan 30, 2024 · Red inks are often used for attention-grabbing writing—from grading papers to Valentine’s Day cards. No box, just the bottle marked with the little blue dot. Eventually, most iron gall ink changes to a brown color, as is evident in Austen’s letters and manuscripts. I have tried the R&K Documentus Dunkelblau, it is very wet and prone to bleed-through. The downside is that it is acidic, and after several decades starts eating away at paper, I think. Two different chromatography's are discussed as well as there is a resistance test done. Have a look around the two ink forums and research any ink before you buy it. The MB Midnight is also the least likely to shade, and has the highest percentage of non-waterproof dye. It seems to be a relatively mild form of Iron Gall while still retaining the best characteristics of a stronger formula. Feb 2, 2023 · Vintage Montblanc Blue Black is an iron gall formulation, and usually quite well behaved, but it does have all of the standard issues that you need to watch out for with Iron Gall ink. How does it compare to normal, dye based inks, and how does it stack up against modern iron gall inks? I’m given to understand it isn’t an iron gall—but how does it perform compared to R&K Salix, or Akkerman’s iron gall or Diamine Registrar’s? Edit: grammar fix. Choose from our picks, or use our swatches and test results to find your own favorite! Apr 10, 2015 · Here's a great example of one of the few fountain pen friendly iron gall inks left on the market (RIP Montblanc Midnight Blue… ). . Are there other permanent/archival fountain pen inks on the market that claim adherence to a certain archival ink standard? Is this important in the legal world? Maybe some FPN members in the legal field 4. Q: What exhibition and display conditions are recommended for items containing iron gall ink? Mar 5, 2012 · Here are scans showing three iron gall inks. Bleed/feather: minimal, characteristic good behavior for an iron gall ink Saturation: medium Color: standard blue black, does darken a bit Jan 7, 2006 · Montblanc manufactures a single iron gall ink, namely Permanent Blue Black. Admittedly, this isn’t a flashy ink. Apr 3, 2025 · Iron Gall inks darken over time as a result of oxidation of the iron content. And I was right. Then I read visvamitra's review of Mont Blanc Midnight Blue, and found another blue-black that spoke to me. Modern formulations of iron gall ink (like the ones made by Platinum, Diamine, Rohrer & Klingner, and others) are safe to use with fountain pens. Check out our oak gall gel selection for the very best in unique or custom, handmade pieces from our dyes & stains shops. Keep reading to see our top red fountain pen ink recommendations, plus comparison tests of all the red inks available at JetPens. My favorite permanent inks are Sailor Seiboku (pigment, but the L2K is easy to clean) and Montblanc Permanent Blue. Rohrer & Klingner makes 'Scabiosa' which is iron-gall, dries fast and permanent. Flow: moderately dry, but not as dry as others such as Registrar's, Salix, etc. I am good at rinsing out my pens regularly and have seen this talked about as a necessity May 25, 2010 · Mont Blanc pens are very tough and their own black ink is an iron gall ink, which should only be used in a pen with a gold nib. You can make normal inks like Waterman, Montblanc, Quink, etc. This is where the not understanding myself comes in to play. Iron gall ink? I've recently bought a Mont Blanc midnight blue and realized it is an iron gall ink. Does anyone use iron gall inks and what are your cleaning procedures? Jun 28, 2022 · Iron gall inks are made with iron sulfate and tannic acids from sources like oak galls. Pigment-Based and Iron-Gall Inks: Instead of dyes, these inks use non-soluble particles suspended in water. Montblanc’s Midnight Blue iron-gall ink changes from a dark blue to a solid, somewhat matte, blue-black color. Feb 2, 2023 · Vintage Montblanc Blue Black is an iron gall formulation, and usually quite well behaved, but it does have all of the standard issues that you need to watch out for with Iron Gall ink. And yes it is used for permanency, as it is waterproof once dry. Herbin and Diamine. The five iron gall inks from Fox & Quills have a higher pH (less acid) than standard iron galls so your nibs won't corrode as quickly. Midnight Blue is being reformulated to a less permanent version. For anyone interested, the Montblanc Midnight Blue product codes are 109204 for the non-IG ink and 105194 for the version supposedly containing IG. What are your favourite iron gall inks? Personally, I go with the R&K inks a lot at the moment, but also used KWZ extensively at some point. Jun 18, 2020 · Ink Review #212: Montblanc Midnight Blue Today we’ll be reviewing Montblanc Midnight Blue that I purchased from r/pen_swap. Independent ink companies which produce safe inks that are readily available are limited to J. Jul 1, 2017 · It is not, however, a replacement for the iron-gall-based Mont Blanc Blue-Black. The new ((bleep)) ink's number is 109204. Dec 12, 2011 · Now: most commercial iron gall inks like Lamy and Mont Blanc rely heavily on the dye component. Short story long: their violet iin a bottle or in a cartridge is "basically" the same, in general a rather dry ink, but not as dry as their blue black in the bottle. Jul 14, 2009 · The general rule is to be extra cautious when mixing inks of different brands or of different "families" -- you shouldn't mix an iron-gall ink (like Montblanc Blue-Black) with any other ink (though the various colors of iron-gall inks from Rohrer & Klingner might mix safely). Good idea to give your pen a rinse every couple of fillings to remove any dried ink on nib/feed. I still have a bottle and you reminded me that I should ink up a pen with it again. Iron Gall Ink History 120 Chromatic Decay Iron gall ink, historically valued for its deep, enduring black, presents a unique case study in chromatic shift over time. The royal blue hasn't changed much since then. I know it was purchased in the early-mid 1990s as the papers it was stored with date it to that period. As far as I am aware, there is a non-permanent, non-iron gall MB Blue Black as well. It was the standard ink formulation used in Europe for the 1400-year period between the 5th and 19th centuries, remained in widespread use well into the 20th century, and is still sold today. Apr 29, 2010 · That iron gall ink is in any case drier than their ink in a cartridge. The company's issued a new, larger (60 ml vs 50 ml) bottle. using only: food colouring dyes, isopropylic alcohol (or HCl), glycerine, salycilic acid, and distilled water. Montblanc permanent ink formulation Hi all Regarding the two currently available Montblanc permanent inks (blue and black), do we know what the formulation is? Iron gall or particulate? I’ve been using the black and the residue seems similar to a sailor KG, but I can’t find any info to back up the type of formulation. Jul 17, 2016 · Ink Shoot-Out : Mont Blanc Midnight Blue vs Pelikan Edelstein Tanzanite Pelikan Edelstein Tanzanite was my very first blue-black ink, and one that I like a lot - it's usually to be found as the perfect companion for my Lamy 2000. However, even KWZ states that Iron-Gall inks require more care from fountain pen users than standard inks. Turquoise, Mandarin and many others also have a very extreme color change. Even then, to avoid clogs, flush and clean the pen every month. Montblanc and other companies don't want to have to worry about people using an iron gall ink that eats out their pen or a calligraphy ink (see india/sumi-e ink) which completely gunks it up) and by recommending only their own products they don't have to cover customer stupidity. Iron gall inks I know about: KWZ Diamine Registrars/Chesterfield Vault ESSRI Rohrer and Klingner Salix/Scabiosa I would love to hear about some more (if there are any). Sep 14, 2017 · Based on my years of experience using iron gall inks, I am confident in iron gall inks from KWZ, Platinum, Pelikan and Rohrer & Klingner. I’m curious to see how Montblanc permanent blue performs. ” 3 days ago · Research on faded press copies from around 1905 found that iron gall ink became most visible at shorter wavelengths below 500 nanometers (blue-violet light), while typewriter ink showed best at 620 nanometers (red-orange light). It and R&K Salix are about even on like-o-meter, but I find myself preferring Registrar's Ink due to its darker final color. One option to consider are iron-gall formula inks. To be honest I find Montblanc bottle not only nice but also practical, much better than Iroshizuku or Sailor. But sometimes, you find yourself inadvertently giving a torture test to an ink that can’t handle it. The new colours laun Oct 21, 2012 · Here's a scan of my written review of Mont Blanc's bottle Midnight Blue ink. Their old inks were made in Germany, now they're from Austria. Depending on the color, iron-gall ink may change when it dries. Nov 13, 2015 · The Montblanc Permanent ink is marked as ISO 14145-2 certified, ie an archival ink standard. Jul 15, 2015 · The KWZI iron galls have some dramatic color change. Sep 19, 2013 · Montblanc is expanding its ink offering to more permanent colors with the addition of a blue and a black that are iron gall based. I'm not talking about bad flow - the ink flows well and pens will put a lot of it on the page - Iron gall inks are generally less lubricating and many people notice more feedback from the nib on the page. Sep 2, 2014 · Here is the Identification number for Montblanc Midnight Blue - iron gall version (now discontinued): 105194 If you find you like it, be sure and buy as much as you can because it will disappear shortly. When exposed to air, the iron elements of the ink oxidize, so the color darkens and becomes resistant to light and dampness. In fact i wouldnt buy a pen that cant whitstand modern IG inks. Has really nice shading and colour to it as well as good water resistance due to it being an iron-gall ink. Non iron gall ink similar to Montblanc midnight blue. And I've also heard that Diamine registrars ink and Rohrer & Klingner Salix are both pretty popular. Pretty sure that if any of the Dutch Masters series were IG inks the description would say so. There are many fans of Montblanc's Midnight Blue as it is a dark blue, almost black with a hint of purple undertone. The sticker on the bottom of the new ink's bottle also says "non perma". Montblanc 'Midnight Blue' is one example, rich dark (almost black) blue. Dec 16, 2020 · The ink flows evenly and easily from premium fountain pens as well as everyday models. Mar 5, 2017 · Iron gall (IG) ink has been around in some form or fashion for about 2,000 years, and it has been widely used since about the Fifth Century. Once they dry, the particles are embedded in the paper and won’t wash away. My sense is that this ink darkens over time. Jan 22, 2020 · So I went through some old boxes on the weekend and discovered a bottle of Montblanc ink in with papers. Oct 25, 2009 · All inks made by pen manufacturers are safe to use. Mar 25, 2015 · I currently have a pen filled with Sheaffer Skrip #22 Permanent Blue-Black ink. KWZ Ink Iron-Gall Blue #2 looks really similar to Montblanc Midnight Blue, a little bit darker maybe. One of the finest inks! Writing Video in the next post. Mar 1, 2020 · Hello, We had another thread going about me having to write on crummy office paper all day, and which ink would be best for legibility (Bleed/feathering, etc), and amongst other things, the topic of Iron-gall inks came up, and a wise veteran of this forum recommended that I start this thread to e Apr 6, 2016 · It seems that in 2010 Montblanc changed the manufacturer of their ink as well as the design of the bottle. Swabs: T his ink had high shading and medium red sheen. Jul 3, 2018 · Midnight is what Montblanc replaced the blue-black with but the '90s stuff had iron gall and is permanent. The latter is especially great on cheap paper. The ink is easy to make, inexpensive, and can be transported as a powder and mixed whenever needed. As the ink dries, the ferrous sulfate is converted to ferric oxide (Fe2O3), which is intensely black. Rohrer & Klingner inks are great for use in fountain pens, quills and other calligraphy utensils. Jan 31, 2016 · That R&K is very good stuff, it flows better for me than Ecclesiastical Stationery Supplies ink. Apr 5, 2012 · Montblanc blue/black has good flow and nice shading, but only the bottled ink has iron gall. Rohrer & Klingner Fountain Pen Ink (50mL) - Eisen-Gallus-Tinte Salix (Iron Gall Blue)With roots in lithography stretching back to 1892, Rohrer & Klingner continues their time-honoured tradition of crafting inks, while utilizing traditional recipes and production methods. Add Montblanc, Lamy, which have in the past sold iron gall fountain pen inks which in my experience are also excellent and trustworthy. May 21, 2009 · I have been gifted with some Montblanc blue black ink (bottled), which I know is an iron gall ink. My advice would be to keep it out of a vintage pen. Jul 17, 2024 · Similarly, any ink that contains iron-gall will have high water-resistance, including the line of Platinum "Classic" inks. New to this subreddit, stumbled on it recently but it seems like the right place to ask this question. Mar 15, 2010 · I dedicate a 149 broad nib with Montblanc iron gall blue black for this purpose. This is a very nice blue-black ink. ’ Montblanc iron gall, according to my hydrion plastic dip strip measured exactly ph neutral (insofar as the strip is accurate, but I used 3) registrars is a bit lower at 6. Yes, I mentioned on the page that Blue Black was discontinued in 2010, and Midnight Blue (the iron gall variant) was only made between 2010-2013. Whoops. Many thanks. Feb 12, 2014 · Before the pictures let me just say, if you're wanting to try and find the old ink out on the market before supply dries up, ask the seller for the product number. They works wonderfully. Remember that Iron-Gall ink is acidic (any acid-free iron-gall anyone?), and it will corrode your pen. Montblanc Midnight Blue fits in that range and I should like it. The old, iron gall ink's number is 105194. Jul 22, 2017 · Like most iron gall inks, Platinum Classic ink feels a little dry for my taste. Ink Review: Montblanc Midnight Blue Background: The old formula Midnight Blue has been a much loved ‘iron gall’ ink, an ink which contains a component that seems to result in fantastic performance, very little bleed and feathering, lots of shading and a degree of water resistance. Montblanc b/b ink cartridges do not contain iron gall, the color is not as permanent as the bottled ink. The current Midnight Blue is, sadly, free of ferrogallic content. I don't. They explain: “According to our ink specialist, the permanent ink no longer have an Iron-Gall content and we have changed to a new ink with black or blue solid pigments. Itˋs a pitty that they discontinued this fantastic ink. ) Jun 23, 2021 · Iron gall ink was invented more than 1500 years ago. 5. The filler and nibs of Mont Blanc pens are not attacked by anything. That might be an alternative if you need something more resistant. The ink, I make, is the contrary: it writes a rather pale blue/greyish blue and darkens into a velvety black and the ultimate colour is almost entirely the IG component. I have no experience with iron gall and vintage pens, and iron gall appears less hazardous than it used to be, but I'd still look for something else. Oct 28, 2014 · Montblanc's Midnight blue when it first came out (Austrian mfg) was iron gall, a great permanent ink but I think they changed it again. Feb 7, 2021 · Krishna Permanent Blue Black Iron Gall A first review for this ink I believe. I'm wondering if anyone knows if it is an iron-gall formulation?? thnx. Beetle Juice Iron Gall Ink. Last edited by Pterodactylus; October 8th, 2020 at 05:42 AM. I'm fond of Toffee Brown and the limited edition Alfred Hitchcok and Winter Glow inks. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. It can affect a cheap stainless alloy nib by corrosion but almost all the nibs I have are gold. Aug 22, 2013 · Montblanc Midnight Blue Ink Review I don't understand myself sometimes. This channel is for Fountain Pen Ink Reviews using a Japanese EF nib Nov 25, 2015 · Modern materials used in quality pens are unaffected by iron gall inks. They dry quickly and don't bleed. Sep 7, 2013 · My favorite Iron Gall ink, and, I feel, the best beginners Iron gall, is Montblanc Midnight Blue. Which they are. I've heard mixed reports on whether or not this should be used in a EEF nib. I have a video of the iron gall gold on the thinking outside the bottle forum. So, it is a comparison of two inks that are no longer available. It was used by innumerable nameless scribes to copy sacred manuscripts; by great secular writers and thinkers such as Voltaire, Shakespeare, and Leibniz; and by ordinary people. The software tool estimates the risk of ink corrosion on specific objects, based on uploaded images and basic information, such as age, and anticipated environmental conditions and handling. Lamy Blue-Black use to be IG also and was reformulated around the same time. You shouldn't mix a pH neutral ink (which is most modern inks) with an alkaline or acidic ink (including many vintage Mar 30, 2021 · Are Iron Gall Inks safe for Gold Nibs? - Q&A Slices Making Medieval Ink // iron gall waterproof black ink Noodler's 54th Massachusetts Fountain Pen Ink #fountainpenink #fountainpens Who Wins? Please keep comments civil. The general opinion on FPN seems to be that iron gall inks are questionable for FPs, but I am uncertain why. So guys, start making your own ink. The candle rub works, but it leaves an greasy film that I just don't like. All are well behaved and attractive inks. another Iron Gall ink still produced commercially is Platinum Blue/Black. Oct 9, 2020 · Re: A Comparison of Montblanc Iron Gall INks MB IG Midnight is an awesome ink, one of my all time favorites. I really like the montblanc midnight blue. (As with pigmented inks, you should clean your pen thoroughly to avoid mixing iron gall inks with standard fountain pen inks, which could result in clogs. The acidity of the ink Non iron gall ink similar to Montblanc midnight blue. Edit: A word on Midnight Blue and any other ferro-gallic/iron gall fountain pen inks. Muralikkrishnan S Jul 7 Montblanc Writers Edition Homage to Robert Louis Stevenson Ink x Platinum Century 3776 14K Laurel Green Fountain Pen x Graphilo Notebook, Japan. Montblanc sold an iron-gall ink (MB Blue-Black) for about 40 years for use in their Montblanc pens. Jan 27, 2008 · OK. Given the new ink is intended for use in MB pens, these inks ought to be relatively safe in any fountain pen. Writes really well, great flow and lubrication. it is a different class of ink, different colour, different behaviour, but still an excellent ink. Mar 7, 2023 · We recommend the best black fountain pen inks for every occasion, from the everyday J. mnazjjsnvoiagwoqvbbcmvhjrgabcnzuabpyrshestdcfeznd